Rare’s Vice President of Asia and Pacific, Nigel Sizer, recently visited Malaysia spending time in Tun Mustapha, and with a local people in the village of Sibogo who are known as Sea Gypsies. Through the series of blogs below, travel with Nigel and learn about dynamite and cyanide fishing practices and how they are tarnishing the areas reefs and marine life. Meet Pride Campaign Manager Suzie Ramlee and hear how she, with WWF and Rare, plan to dramatically reduce destructive fishing in the area.

The village of Sibogo in Malaysia, home of the “Sea Gypsies.”
A View from the Top
I left home in Bali in the early evening for the three-hour flight to Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia’s gleaming, modern capital. It’s always a bit odd flying into their new international airport since it is completely surrounded by vast oil palm plantations, quite unlike any other major airport I have seen. This always helps remind me of the continuing need to build the economies of Southeast Asia, but also how much of this growth comes at the expense of biological diversity. Where Kuala Lumpur’s airport and verdant oil palm now stands there was once luxuriant lowland tropical rainforest, home to tapir, tigers and countless other species.
Meeting, Greeting, and A New Face Joins the Team
Ralph Dixon, who works closely with Ruth Yeoh, a member of Rare’s Board of Trustees who is from Malaysia, joined me for breakfast and an update on Rare’s program in Malaysia and the region. Thanks to support from Ruth and her family, Rare was able to launch a new program in Malaysia in 2008. The first Pride campaign in the country is now underway in partnership with WWF Malaysia. The campaign aims to build community support for marine conservation in the region soon to become the Tun Mustapha Marine Park, located at the far northern tip on the island of Borneo, in the Malaysian state of Sabah.
The afternoon was spent with WWF Malaysia’s senior management team at their offices just outside Kuala Lumpur in Petaling Jaya, affectionately known as “PJ.” I have yet to find a taxi driver who can find their way to this office without recourse to several phone calls to the ever-patient WWF receptionist.
Dato Dr Dino Sharma, WWF’s CEO, met me for a discussion about our ongoing partnership and potential for future collaboration. He and senior colleagues are keen to see more Pride training partnerships with WWF staff and sites around the country. In the short term these will have a marine conservation focus.
In the evening I had a lovely dinner with Sudeep Mohandas, his wife Padma, and their two teenage girls. After ten years with WWF Malaysia, currently serving as head of operations and deputy to the CEO, Sudeep has decided to join Rare’s team and will become our first Director for Southeast Asia. His family had lots of questions about the pending move to Bogor, Indonesia, where our regional office is located. We look forward to having Sudeep join our team starting the beginning of July this year. Meanwhile, his top priority is to recruit and train a successor and ensure a smooth transition at WWF.
Great Prospects: The Tun Mustaphe Marine Park
I was up at four am for the first flight to Kota Kinabalu, capital of Sabah State. Here I met up with Rare Pride Program Manager, Hari Kushardanto, as well as Rejani Kunjappan, who leads WWF Malaysia’s national team of community outreach specialists.

Suzie, Rejani, and Hari.
Sabah is one of the region’s top tourist destinations, and it’s immediately obvious why. The city is small, green, and sits beside a wide breezy bay with views of forest-covered islands. Bars and restaurants line the seafront. A few miles inland mighty Mount Kinabalu rises to its peak at 13, 400 feet above sea level, with temperatures that plunge below freezing at night. The lower slopes of the mountain are covered in tropical rain forest. The state is dotted with forest reserves and is one of the world’s top scuba diving and ecotourism locations.
We jumped into WWF’s minivan, painted with environmental slogans, turtles and fish, and drove four hours north to the sleepy fishing town of Kudat. There we met up with Pride Campaign Manager Suzianah Ramlee (“Suzie”) and her colleague Sofia. Both serve as WWF Malaysia’s community outreach officers for the vast area of ocean and islands north of Kudat. This one million hectare plus region is slated to become the Tun Mustaphe Marine Park.
Dynamite Fishing Destruction
We all gathered for a traditional Malaysian breakfast of nasi lemak (rice cooked in coconut with a spicy chili sauce, peanuts, boiled egg and fried anchovies sprinkled on top – really delicious!), except Hari, who seems to prefer cake – and lots of it — to get his energy up before a day out in the islands.
By eight o’clock we were in WWF’s speedboat, and with 200 horsepower engines behind us we sped out into the ocean, ably guided by Asri, WWF’s master scuba diver, and an equally skilled boat captain.
Our first stop, about 45 minutes from Kudat, was the home of Mr. Jamili, his wife and seven children, ranging from strapping young men in their twenties to a one-year-old still happily breast feeding. Friendly cats, fat in fish, quickly found warm homes on our laps as we chatted.

Jamili, far right, speaks to the group. Nigel, far left, listens in.
Jamili has taken the extraordinary initiative of personally protecting a wide area of ocean in front his beachfront home. This area sustains his family with fish which are put on ice and sold fresh in Kudat. It’s hard to say how large the area is that he is managing, but it looked to be over 200 hectares.
The problem is that young men from nearby villages, and even as far afield as the Philippines, are keen to get their hands on Jamili’s fish, and their preferred method is using homemade bombs or cyanide. Throwing a bomb in the water kills hundreds of fish instantly, some of which float up to the top of the water and are quickly gathered. Their flesh is damaged, but they can be dried and salted and are then indistinguishable from fish caught normally. Cyanide is squirted into the water and stuns fish, making them easy to catch live, put into water-filled containers and then sold to the live fish trade, with high prices paid by restaurants in local towns, and even as far away as Kuala Lumpur, Singapore and Hong Kong. The cyanide kills the reef and some fish and is highly destructive. Both bomb and cyanide fishing are strictly illegal in Malaysia, but enforcement is hard along the thousands of kilometers of coastline.

Live fish, caught with Cyanide, waiting for sale.
Jamili’s efforts to keep out the bombs and cyanide have landed him in trouble. Fishermen have threatened to kill him and he and his family now live in fear of retribution. The Malaysian government does not formally recognize his resource use rights, and the local marine police are stretched to help him. WWF Malaysia has done a great job of offering him moral support, starting to highlight his plight with the local government agencies. They’ve given him a camera so that he can photograph those he sees using illegal fishing techniques and this has resulted in the marine police confiscating boats and equipment.

Jamili and Nigel at the locally managed protected area.
The Pride campaign led by Suzie will further highlight the efforts of Jamili, and others like him in the area, enhancing their status in the communities, encouraging government agencies to better recognize these community-led conservation efforts, and building upon them to create larger locally managed marine areas. They will also organize meetings to get like-minded locals together to help them plan and support each other in their efforts, and assist them to become honorary wildlife wardens under a scheme developed by the government.
An Afternoon with Sea Gypsies and Pride’s Call to Action

Sibogo, the village on stilts.
From Jamili’s idyllic beach we ploughed through the waves for another hour on the WWF launch to visit the other end of the illegal destructive fishing problem.
The village of Sebogor appears in the distance to be floating on the water complete with a mosque. As we got closer we could see that it is entirely built on stilts, apparently with no connection to the nearby land. It is home to about 100 families of Orang Bajau people or “sea gypsies”. These remarkable communities spend their entire existences living over the ocean, and occasionally dismantle their sturdy wooden homes and relocate to fresh and less depleted fishing grounds. The people of Sebogor have an even more colorful past. They are refugees who fled the fighting in the Philippines in the 1960s. Many are now fully legal residents of Malaysia, but some are stateless with limited or no rights, prone to harassment and even deportation by the authorities. The village is also in the so-called “red zone,” where there is elevated risk of kidnapping and other threats – fortunately our WWF colleagues had not told Hari and me about this before we arrived, so we were happily oblivious to any danger!

A resident of Sibogo
From a distance the village looks grim, ramshackle, and appears to be an extremely unpleasant place to eek out a living, raise children and grow old in the hot, salty humidity barely a stone’s throw from the maritime border with the Philippines.
I was surprised and deeply impressed when we tied up at their jetty and were greeted by one of the village elders. Nearby four men, immensely skilled, were building the 10 meter hull of a boat, perched above the water on rickety planks. With no sign of plans, or tools other than a hammer, a power drill (they have a generator), and some chisels, the beautiful traditional boat was taking shape. They said they would sell it when complete for about USD12,000. Women were smoking dried sea cucumbers in a large circular tray. Young men tended to buckets full of hundreds of abalone, soon to be sold to traders from Kudat for a handsome profit. The homes were spacious and airy, and many had televisions and radios, refrigerators and fans.

Sea cucumbers being dried and smoked.
We were taken to the home of the village elder that had met us, and sat on the floor with his family. The bookshelves were full, and I noted thick tomes in English on financial management theory. He explained that his older children had gone to university in Malaysia, and many in the village had made the pilgrimage to Mecca. My perception of this as a hardscrabble community living on the edge of extreme poverty was changing! These are entrepreneurial, hard-working people, who manage to send their children to higher education, practice extraordinary craftsmanship with their boat building, and have a rich cultural life centered around their stilted mosque.

The group talking with the village elder.
They also seem perfectly happy to use bombs and cyanide as their preferred fishing techniques. They spoke openly about this, even though it is illegal. When asked if they were concerned about declining fish stocks and damage to resources, they responded that if the fish disappear then they will simply move. We also know that the men who have threatened to kill Jamili probably live in Sebogor. The police very rarely come to the village.
From Sebogor we headed to the main town on the island of Banggi, where Suzie grew up. There, WWF has built a colorful environmental education center, open to all the local people, showing videos, organizing environmental events, and rallying an energetic and growing cadre of local volunteers, all wearing bright blue WWF T-shirts.

Nigel with the WWF volunteers.
Our final stop was a small island south of Banggi, called Maliangin, where we donned scuba gear and made a quick underwater tour of one of the better diving sites in the area. There is very little scuba diving in Tun Mustapha. The visibility tends to be a bit low, and the overfishing and destructive fishing have eliminated most of the larger fish and damaged much of the coral. But we did see quite good coral cover and diversity, even though there was evidence of probable damage from bombing (characterized by lots of coral rubble and large broken pieces of coral) and cyanide (leaving telltale patches of dead, white coral). I was struck most, however, by the fish life. While the diversity looked high, I didn’t see a single fish longer than about six inches – the classic sign of overfishing. With the large predator fish so depleted the ecology of the entire reef changes, and, of course, the local fishery suffers.

Large fish for sale.
Campaign Manager Suzie is daunted by the challenge of reducing illegal fishing by the people of Sebogor and other nearby communities. But has a few cards up her sleeve. She grew up nearby and her father is a prominent imam. She is completely at ease with the local people who welcome her into their homes.
That evening we discussed how she will use social marketing to begin to build awareness about the impacts and dangers associated with destructive fishing, and thereby start to change attitudes. The village imams, wives and children of fishermen could all help to catalyze conversations about these issues, in turn leading at least some in the communities to start to question their heavy involvement in blast and poison fishing, and become more open to alternatives.
Meanwhile, Rare has some homework to do. Hari and I will find a regional specialist in alternatives to destructive fishing and get that person to Tun Mustapha by mid-April to help WWF put together a detailed plan to provide alternative fishing techniques to the local communities. Pride will open minds to different practices and as soon as that happens, WWF must be ready to help the fishermen adopt new approaches.
Plans for Pride, Plans Malaysia

Back in Kudat, after a very good night’s sleep, we regrouped over breakfast to agree on next steps and encourage Suzie to make the next big steps with her campaign. Then it was the long drive back to Kota Kinabalu. That afternoon, Hari, Rejani and I, met with Robecca Jumin, Suzie’s supervisor, and Ken Kassem, who leads WWF’s marine program in Sabah. We brought Rebecca up to speed and agreed to keep in close touch with weekly phone calls in the months to come. Frequent communication is key to head off any problems and challenges before they become overly serious.
We ended our visit by hearing from Ken about Semporna, a new site for WWF, where work is about to begin on a major marine conservation program. The site includes world-famous Sipadan island, the top scuba diving destination in Malaysia, and many other extraordinary reefs and communities. Once again, overfishing and destructive fishing top the list of threats at this new site. Rare Pride training will begin there next year, together – we hope – with eleven other sites facing similar challenges. Suzie’s pioneering efforts in Tun Mustapha will help chart the course that many others will follow and she will soon graduate from being a trainee to being one of Pride’s many alumni, mentoring other campaign managers across Sabah and beyond.